Blog
Common Furnace Problems Poughkeepsie Homeowners Face (And What to Do About Them)

Hudson Valley winters are harsh, with regular freezing temperatures and adverse winter weather. When your furnace acts up in these conditions, it can be stressful and even dangerous.
Many Hudson Valley homes have older heating systems that are prone to problems. This guide helps you understand the most common furnace problems in Poughkeepsie, what might be causing them, and when it's time to call a professional.
Your Furnace Won't Turn On
This is the most common and most alarming issue, but there are some quick DIY checks you can make. These simple fixes may be just what you need to restore heat.
- Check thermostat settings and replace batteries
- Check for a tripped breaker
- Check for pilot light/ignition issues
- Check the gas supply
If basic troubleshooting doesn't work, it’s time to call professional furnace repair services to diagnose the issue safely and restore heat quickly.
Furnace Blowing Cold Air
Sometimes, furnaces still have power, but only blow cool air. It’s the opposite of what you need in the freezing New York winter. This may be caused by:
- Incorrect thermostat setting, such as the fan set to ON instead of AUTO
- Dirty air filter
- Pilot light and ignition problems
- Overheating safety shutoff
- Ductwork leaks
Dirty filters are by far the most common root cause of cool air. Simply turn your furnace off, change your filters, and turn it back on.
Furnace Keeps Turning On and Off (Short Cycling)
Furnace short cycling is when your heating system frequently stops and starts without completing a full heating cycle. The causes may be:
- Dirty filter causing airflow restriction and overheating
- Thermostat issues
- Blocked vents
- Overheating heat exchanger
- Poorly sized furnace
Short cycling wastes energy and wears out components faster. Professional diagnosis is usually needed to find and fix the problem.
Strange Noises Coming from Your Furnace
Your furnace should gently hum, not make loud, disturbing noises. Strange furnace noises rarely resolve on their own, and small issues can escalate into costly repairs or emergency breakdowns if left unaddressed.
- Banging or Popping: Loud metal-like pops often point to delayed ignition, dirty burners, or expanding ductwork, which is common in older Poughkeepsie homes and should be checked.
- Squealing: High-pitched squeals usually indicate worn blower belts or failing motor bearings that can worsen quickly without proper repair.
- Rattling: Clanging or rattling sounds are often caused by loose panels or internal components.
- Rumbling or Booming: Deep rumbling noises may signal dirty burners and gas buildup before ignition, posing serious safety risks.
Uneven Heating or Cold Spots
Uneven heating or random cold spots in different areas of your house may indicate larger issues that shouldn’t be ignored. Ductwork problems, including leaks and blockages, are common in older Dutchess County homes with original ductwork. Problems such as dirty filters, blower issues, and poor insulation can also cause uneven heating.
Professional duct cleaning and inspection is often the best solution. The experts can diagnose the root cause and implement efficient fixes.
Rising Energy Bills
30-44% of the energy that powers old, low-efficiency furnaces is wasted and does not turn into heat. New, high-efficiency furnaces only lose 1.5-10% of their energy. Your aging, inefficient furnace may be working much harder than it needs to heat your home.
This, combined with dirty filters, duct leaks, and a lack of maintenance, can result in astronomical utility bills. If your furnace is 15-20+ years old, furnace replacement may be a more economical option than continuing to pay for repairs and rising energy bills.
A programmable thermostat can also help by automatically regulating temperatures, reducing wasted energy when you’re asleep or away from home.
Safety Warning: When to Act Immediately
If you notice any of the following issues, turn off the furnace immediately and call a professional.
- Unusual or Persistent Odors: A brief burning smell at the start of heating season is normal, but ongoing smells like burning plastic, rotten eggs, or gas can signal a dangerous leak.
- Abnormal Pilot Light or Flame Color: A healthy furnace flame should be steady and blue. A yellow or flickering flame indicates incomplete combustion, which can lead to dangerous carbon monoxide release.
- Signs of a Cracked Heat Exchanger: Warning signs include frequent furnace shutdowns, strong chemical or formaldehyde-like smells, soot buildup around the unit, or carbon monoxide alarms going off.
Keep carbon monoxide detectors in good working order, and leave the home if you notice a gas smell that doesn’t go away. For any safety concern or no-heat emergency, call for T. Webber’s emergency heating services. We’re available 24/7 for all your emergency heating needs.
Simple Furnace Maintenance You Can Do
Use these maintenance tips to prevent furnace problems in Poughkeepsie and keep your heating systems in excellent condition.
- Change the air filter every 1-3 months
- Keep vents clear
- Check thermostat batteries
- Schedule annual professional tune-up before the heating season
T. Webber Total Care Club members get easy, expert preventive maintenance without the stress.
When to Call a Furnace Professional
DIY isn't always enough. Call a professional if you have any gas or safety concerns, recurring problems, electrical issues, furnaces over 15 years old with frequent problems, or anything you're uncomfortable doing yourself.
T. Webber has served Hudson Valley since 1989, and we understand local homes and the area's unique heating challenges. With our 24/7 availability, your family is never left in the cold. Whether you need emergency repair or want to schedule a heating tune-up before the next Hudson Valley winter, T. Webber's certified technicians are here to help.




